I said I wouldn't, but I've gone and listened to Chinese Democracy. Are you really surprised? But I didn't download - figuring that it's on their Myspace, I thought that was ok. They're happy with us hearing it now. And the temptation was too much to resist!
Overall thoughts...I've heard most of this album already, and you all know that I really like it. I like that it's not identical to old Guns, because we have
Appetite for that. Some songs do sound oversaturated and overproduced, like there's just too much going on. Notably in the songs that have already leaked quite a few times, and each time you hear a new version there's some new layer of backing vocals and guitar work shoved in to make it sound a bit different. But I still think the album's fabulous. Anyway:
Chinese Democracy - I like that it's a balls to the wall rock song, without being Welcome to the Jungle part 2. It makes you want to start singing along 'It don't really matter!' It's not the strongest track on the album, though. And I still wonder how much of the public is really going to 'get' this song, and most of the other songs on the album. Seems like everyone's expecting the exact same band as the early '90s.
Shackler's Revenge - I didn't like this at first, but I really like the final version. But if you're only a fan of the old Guns I really don't know if you're going to appreciate this.
Better - I've never much liked Better's intro, but the first couple of verses are great. Then it gets loaded down with a lot of guitar effects which bother my ears a bit. Though I like tracks where Axl sounds angry, as he does on this one. He does that well, and this song appears to be the one that the lay people like best too.
Street Of Dreams - This will always be
The Blues to me! It's the album's first ballady song (I'm reluctant to call it an all-out ballad), but Axl's no Bon Jovi, so don't worry - Axe does
good ballads! Actually Axl's strength lies in his ballady songs. But I do like that they've shoved some more guitar in this song so it's no longer a tinkly piano ballad. The guitar from the '01/'02 versions was perhaps better, but what they've got now is enough to give the song the oomph it needs. Perhaps if Axl sang it in a deeper voice it could sound better though - too much helium - but the last minute or so is incredible, as he's singing his heart out.
If The World - Flows a good deal better than in the leaks from June. It's not my favorite though. Axl's voice hurts my ears in parts, but it's something different! Are people going to be weirded out by hearing a song like this on a GN'R album though?
There Was A Time - TWAT! My old favorite from 2006! I really wish they hadn't kept that choir in the beginning, but as the first verse kicks in and the guitar line follows the melody, it sounds good. I'm not so keen on 'It was a long time for you...' part - too much guitar making a noise in the background there. Now the reason why it was my favorite back then - the guitar solo. Buckethead! Buckethead's actually good, even if he does look rather ridiculous! The solo goes where you want it to go, it's perfectly satisfying. Really.
Catcher In The Rye - First things first; they should have kept Brian May on this song. The song sounded better with him, and it would have to have remained more stripped down to showcase his parts. This is one of the main culprits for having way too many guitars in it. Axl's vocals are almost drowned at points because of all the millions of guitars. But after thinking it wasn't going to be on the album, I'm glad that it's here. It is a good song. Near the end we start getting that climbing piano/synthy effect in the background which I quite enjoy, although it sounds like it's taken right out of Ozzy's
See You On The Other Side.
Scraped - Oooh ouch, nooo, this is horrible... At least that's what I thought during the intro. Seriously, what are they doing there? Then the song proper started and we're treated to Oh My God Part II. It's ok, but I wouldn't rave about it. It has some great bits, others not so great. I think it'll be a grower though.
Sorry - Another song I hadn't heard before! And freakin' amazing at that. I love it. It's true that there is a line near the start where Axl sounds like a mix between Derek Zoolander and Count Dracula, but then that chorus kicks in with the ominous sounding guitar, and Axl's voice is so different on this one, and he's pissed off again in this one, and I love this one so much! I am gonna say it's possibly the best track on the record. Say what you want about the actual lyrical content - I'm not good enough at this stuff to analyze their meaning - but I love the way the lyrics are put together.
Riad N' The Bedouins - I can't find anything negative to say about Riad, but I also can't find anything positive to say. So I suppose that's a negative thing. It's definitely not
bad, but it's never really caught my interest.
IRS - The first version of this song leaked almost ten years ago.
Ten! Well...if the album had a secret weapon, it wouldn't be this. But I've always liked it anyway. Although I liked the 2006 leaked version best with that big booming guitar riff more obvious underneath the whole thing. Once again it's become oversaturated with too many guitars.
Madagascar - It's nice to hear Axl veering away from his helium voice for a bit. I still think they could've trimmed down the vocal clips in the middle though. It's not my favorite, but I don't usually skip it when I listen to the leaks.
This I Love - First time I heard it I really didn't like it, but it grows on me more and more each time I listen, which is always a definite sign that I'll come to love a song. I just like the general sadness and the minor key (I think it's a minor key - been ages since I studied music), Axl's deep voice at the beginning, the contrasts between the different parts of the songs, and the piano and strings providing a good contrast to the heavy guitar work on other parts of the album.
Prostitute - Very strong track. I like to think this is the one he's singing to Slash! This song is epic and it's the perfect way to close the album. 'Nuff said.
Is this album worth all the millions of dollars and 15 years of waiting? No. Can you think of an album that is? That's impossible. So take it for what it is. Let's face it, if this album hadn't taken so long to come out then it would be getting rave reviews. The time it took to make is the issue people have, but I'm not looking at it that way. Best songs...
Sorry, This I Love and
Prostitute!
But why has there been no promotion? Ok, I live in the UK, where people have awful music taste and probably wouldn't care about Guns N' Roses at all, but I've not seen a single thing about the album anywhere. And Axl hasn't done any promotion, no interviews, no radio appearances... What's up with that? Either way, I can't wait to go into HMV on Monday and pick up my copy!